PrimeWay Blog

Cash vs. Gold vs. Bitcoin vs. Money Market: The Ultimate Investment Guide for {{ hubdb_table_rows('promo_codes_and_rates')[17].year}} | PrimeWay Federal Credit Union

Written by Laurie Masera Garza | Dec 6, 2024 9:25:00 PM

Cash vs. Gold vs. Bitcoin vs. Money Market: Choosing and Balancing Your Investments

When people think about growing their money, they often jump straight into choosing investments. They might ask themselves: “Should I keep cash or buy gold? Should I invest in Bitcoin or should I put money into a money market fund?” These are good questions, but there’s something else you should do first: pay off high-interest debt.

If you have a credit card charging 20% interest each year, it’s very hard for any investment to beat that. Even a good investment that earns 10% a year will not help much, because you’re still losing money to the high interest on your debt. So, the smartest first step is to pay off or at least lower any high-interest debt before you start investing. Once your debt is under control, you can build wealth without your earnings being eaten up by interest payments.

After you get rid of high-interest debt, it’s time to consider where to put your money. In this article, we will compare four popular places to hold your savings or investments: cash, gold, Bitcoin and money market accounts or funds. We will explain each choice, discuss their histories, talk about how quickly you can turn them into usable money (liquidity), consider how they handle inflation, look at their price stability (volatility) and think about the rules and laws that affect them. We’ll also talk about how safe they are to store, whether they produce income, their long-term buying power and what role they might play in your overall financial plan. Finally, we’ll give ideas on how you might split your investments among these four options.

1. What Are These Four Asset Types?

  • Cash: Cash is the paper and coins in your wallet and the money in your checking or savings account. Governments print and control cash. Everyone understands it and it’s easy to use for buying things. Cash doesn’t grow much by itself, but it is simple and always accepted.
  • Gold: Gold is a shiny, yellow metal used for thousands of years as money, jewelry and a symbol of wealth. Many people see gold as a “safe” place to store value, especially in uncertain times. You can own physical gold (coins or bars) or “paper gold” like gold-based funds. Gold doesn’t pay interest, but it often keeps its value over the long run.
  • Bitcoin: Bitcoin is a digital currency that started in 2009. It isn’t controlled by any government. Instead, it runs on a technology called “blockchain,” which keeps track of all transactions. Bitcoin is known for big price swings—sometimes its value changes a lot in a short time. Some people think of it like “digital gold” because it has a limited supply. Others see it as a risky bet. Whether it’s good or bad depends on how you feel about technology, risk and the future of money.
  • Money Market Accounts or Funds: A money market account or fund invests in short-term, low-risk loans and government securities. These are seen as very safe. They often pay a bit more interest than a simple checking account, but not as much as riskier investments. Money market funds are good for parking cash you might need soon, earning a small amount of interest while staying fairly safe.

Comparative Analysis: Cash, Gold, Bitcoin and Money Market


Feature Cash Gold Bitcoin Money Market
Definition Government-issued fiat currency Physical precious metal Digital cryptocurrency Short-term financial instruments
Year Introduced Modern fiat: 1971 5000+ BCE 2009 Early 1900s
Liquidity Rating Highest (5/5) Moderate (3/5) Variable (2-4/5) High (4/5)
Inflation Protection Poor (-2/5) Strong (4/5) Potential (3/5) Moderate (2/5)
Volatility Lowest (1/5) Moderate (3/5) Highest (5/5) Very Low (1/5)
Regulatory Clarity Highest (5/5) High (4/5) Evolving (2/5) High (4/5)
Storage Complexity Low (1/5) High (4/5) Moderate (3/5) Low (1/5)
Long-term Value Poor (1/5) Strong (4/5) Unknown (?) Moderate (3/5)

 

2. How Long Have They Been Around?

  • Cash: Paper money has existed for hundreds of years in different forms. Modern cash, which is not backed by gold anymore, has been the standard for most countries only in the last century or so. For example, the U.S. dollar stopped being tied to gold in 1971.
  • Gold: Gold has been valued for thousands of years, going back to ancient times. It has survived many wars, changes in governments and economic events. Humans have trusted gold as a symbol of wealth for a very long time.
  • Bitcoin: Bitcoin is new. It started in 2009. So, compared to cash and gold, it has a very short history. In just over a decade, it has gone from something few people knew about to a well-known (but still debated) asset.
  • Money Market Instruments: Money markets and their related products have been around for about a century, really growing in importance in the mid-1900s. They became popular as a safe place to hold short-term funds and as a way for banks, companies and governments to manage their daily finances. PrimeWay’s Money Market Account offers competitive rates, making it a reliable choice for Houston-area residents looking to grow their savings.

3. Liquidity: How Easy Is It to Turn Them Into Cash You Can Spend?

  • Cash: Cash is the most liquid asset. You can use it right away to buy goods and services. Money in your checking account can be spent with a debit card or withdrawn from an ATM instantly.
  • Gold: Gold is fairly liquid. You can usually sell it to dealers or pawn shops or trade it on the market. However, selling gold might take a bit of effort and you may face a difference between the price you get and the price you see quoted online. You might have to wait a few days to get your money.
  • Bitcoin: Bitcoin can be turned into cash through online exchanges. Under normal conditions, you can sell it quickly, often within minutes or hours. But you must have an account on an exchange, follow their rules and pay fees. Sometimes, if the market is very busy or crashed, it might be slower or harder to sell.
  • Money Market Accounts : Money market accounts may not offer the same instant access as cash in your wallet, but you can typically access your funds within a day or so. They are considered both very safe and highly liquid, allowing you to move money in and out with minimal or no penalties.

4. How Does Inflation Affect Them?

  • Cash: Inflation means that prices of goods and services rise, so your money buys less over time. Cash does not grow by itself (except for small amounts of interest in a savings account), so inflation eats away at its value. A dollar today will likely buy fewer things 10 years from now.
  • Gold: Gold is often thought of as a good “inflation hedge.” Over very long periods, gold tends to keep up with or even beat inflation. Although gold’s price can go up and down, it has held value over centuries and does not become worthless when prices rise.
  • Bitcoin: Bitcoin has a fixed supply—only 21 million coins can ever exist. Some people think this makes it good against inflation. But since it’s so new and its price swings so wildly, it’s not proven that it truly protects against inflation. It might, but we don’t know for sure over the very long term.
  • Money Market Accounts: Money market accounts pay interest, which sometimes goes up if inflation and interest rates rise. But over many years, inflation could still reduce the buying power of your money in these accounts.

5. Volatility: Do Their Prices Swing Wildly?

  • Cash: One dollar is always one dollar in your home country. So, there is no volatility in terms of how many dollars you have. However, the “real value” of that dollar changes with inflation. Still, day to day, the number doesn’t jump around.
  • Gold: Gold prices do change based on markets, but not as wildly as Bitcoin or some stocks. Gold can have big moves, but generally it’s seen as more stable than very volatile investments. Over time, its value is steadier than many other assets.
  • Bitcoin: Bitcoin is well-known for big price swings. Its price can jump up or down by 10% or even more in a single day. This volatility is one of the biggest reasons people are unsure about investing in it.
  • Money Market Accounts: These are very stable. The value of the main amount (principal) usually does not change much. The interest rate can change, but you normally don’t see the value suddenly drop. They are considered one of the safest places to keep money while still earning a small return. PrimeWay’s Money Market Account combines high returns and flexibility, giving you peace of mind for your savings.