PrimeWay Blog

Venmo vs Zelle® vs PayPal vs Cash App: {{ hubdb_table_rows('promo_codes_and_rates')[17].year}} Comprehensive Comparison | PrimeWay Federal Credit Union

Written by Laurie Masera Garza | Apr 17, 2025 8:21:24 PM

Venmo vs Zelle® vs PayPal vs Cash App: Deep‑Dive Guide

Person‑to‑person payment apps make it easy to move money with a phone. In the U.S., four names lead the pack:

  • Venmo: A fun, social way to pay friends. Owned by PayPal.
  • Zelle®: Runs inside many bank apps. Money moves straight between bank accounts.
  • PayPal: The first big online wallet. Now covers both people and full‑size shops.
  • Cash App: Simple screen, loved by younger users. Adds stocks and Bitcoin.

Together these services have more than 250 million U.S. accounts and handle over $1 trillion each year.

Quick picks

Good for… App Main reason
Splitting dinner or rent with friends Venmo Built‑in split tool, fun social feed
Fast, no‑fee bank‑to‑bank transfers Zelle® Money lands in checking in minutes
Online buying and sending money overseas PayPal Buyer protection plus global reach
Teens learning money skills & side‑gig pay Cash App Teen accounts with parent view, Cash Card

 

Venmo

Born in 2009 and acquired by PayPal in 2013, Venmo popularized the idea that payments could be fun—complete with emoji‑laden public timelines. Core personal transfers are free when funded via debit, ACH or existing Venmo balance, while credit‑card funding costs 3 %. Instant transfer to a bank‑linked debit card costs 1.75 % (min $0.25, max $25).

Key 2024–25 milestones:

  • Teen Accounts (13‑17) with guardian‑controlled debit card.
  • Crypto trading (Bitcoin, Ethereum) inside the Venmo app.
  • Business Profiles: sellers pay 1.9 % + $0.10 on any payment ≥ $1.

Zelle®

Zelle® is a bank‑owned network (Early Warning Services, LLC), embedded into 2,100 + financial‑institution apps. It moves money via RTP‑style instant ACH memo posting, so funds land in the recipient’s checking account within minutes—no wallet, no stored balance.

  • Consumer & small‑business usage is entirely fee‑free (banks do not levy per‑item charges).
  • Funding sources restricted to U.S. deposit accounts; cards & credit lines not supported.
  • No purchase‑protection program—payments are irrevocable once authorised.

Zelle®’s strongest value prop is cost and speed; weakest is lack of tooling (no split button, no teen accounts, limited dispute resolution).

PayPal

PayPal governs the broadest product surface:

  • P2P “Friends & Family” (free via bank / PayPal balance, 2.9 % + $0.30 if sender uses card).
  • Merchant processing online checkout, PayPal Zettle POS, subscriptions, payouts.
  • Seller Protection + Buyer Protection frameworks.
  • Global reach: 200 + markets, 100 + currencies.

Standard U.S. online checkout pricing: 3.49 % + $0.49 per domestic transaction.  Instant withdrawals mirror Venmo at 1.75 % (max $25).

PayPal owns Venmo, which strategically positions the group to cover both social P2P and traditional e‑commerce.

Cash  App

Cash App is super easy to use:
Just open the app, type in how much money you want to send, and press Pay.

What makes it special:

  • Cash Card: A Visa debit card you can use to spend your Cash App balance. You can also get special "Boost" discounts when you use it.
  • Bitcoin and stocks: You can buy and sell Bitcoin, and even invest small amounts in stocks.
  • Teen accounts: Kids ages 13–17 can have accounts with a parent or guardian’s approval.
  • Business option: If you sell things, you can switch to a business account. Cash App takes 2.75% from each payment you receive.

Deposits:

  • Instant deposits (right away) cost 0.5%–1.75%, just like Venmo.
  • Standard deposits (1–3 business days) are free.

Venmo vs Zelle® vs PayPal vs Cash App: Fee Structure Comparison

Feature/Fee Type Venmo Zelle® PayPal Cash App
Send Money (Bank/Debit/Balance) Free Free (via participating banks) Free (Bank/Balance) Free
Send Money (Credit Card) 3% Not Supported 2.9% + Fixed Fee* 3%
Receive Money (Personal) Free Free Free Free
Instant Transfer Fee (Cash Out) 1.75% (Min $0.25, Max $25) N/A (Direct to bank) 1.75% (Min $0.25, Max $25) 0.5% - 1.75% (Min $0.25)
Standard Transfer Fee (Cash Out) Free (1-3 biz days) N/A (Direct to bank) Free (1-3+ biz days) Free (1-3 biz days)
Business Payment Received Fee 1.9% + $0.10* Varies by Bank Offering Varies (e.g., ~2.99% + Fixed Fee)* 2.75%*
International Transfer Fee N/A (US Only) N/A (US Only) Yes, Varies by country/currency N/A (Primarily US/UK)
Currency Conversion Fee N/A (USD Only) N/A (USD Only) Yes, Varies Likely applies for US-UK

 

How Different Money Apps Work for Regular People

What Regular People Use These Apps For

People use these money apps for everyday things like splitting bills with friends, paying back family, or making small purchases. When choosing an app, people care about low fees, how easy it is to use, and if it's safe to send money to people they know.

Venmo

Venmo is very popular, especially with younger adults. It has a social feed where you can see your friends' payments (but not the amounts). This makes payments feel more fun and social.

You can connect Venmo to your bank account, debit card, credit card, or use money already in your Venmo account. It's free to send money using your bank account, debit card, or Venmo balance. Using a credit card costs 3% extra. There's no fee to receive money.

When moving money from Venmo to your bank, you have two choices:

  • Regular transfers: Free but takes 1-2 business days
  • Fast transfers: Costs 1.75% (at least 25¢, up to $25) but money arrives right away

Payments between Venmo users happen instantly within the app.

When you first sign up, you can only send about $300 until you verify your identity. After that, you can send up to about $60,000 per week, which is enough for most personal needs.

Venmo's design is modern and easy to use. It has a built-in way to split bills with groups of friends. After paying for something, you can hit "Split" to divide the cost among friends. You can also use emojis in your payment notes to make them more personal.

For safety, Venmo uses encryption and offers PIN codes and two-step verification. But it's important to know that personal payments have limited protection. If you send money to the wrong person or get scammed, Venmo usually won't give your money back. It's meant for sending money to people you trust, not strangers.

Besides just sending money to friends, you can also use Venmo at some online stores. There's a free Venmo Debit Card that lets you spend your Venmo balance at any place that takes Mastercard.

Good Things About Venmo:

  • Free to send money from bank accounts or debit cards
  • Instant payments to other Venmo users
  • Easy to use with social features and bill-splitting
  • High sending limits once verified
  • Very popular with younger people

Not-So-Good Things About Venmo:

  • 3% fee when using a credit card
  • 1.75% fee for instant transfers to your bank
  • No protection if you send money to the wrong person or get scammed
  • The social feed might show too much of your business if you don't adjust the settings

Zelle®

Zelle® works differently. It's a bank-to-bank transfer service built into many U.S. banking apps. It lets you send money directly from one bank account to another almost instantly.

The biggest advantages of Zelle® are speed and cost: transfers happen almost right away and are completely free. There are no fees to send or receive money. However, it only works with bank accounts – you can't use credit cards or debit cards directly.

When both people use Zelle® through their banks, money moves directly between bank accounts and is available immediately or within minutes. This makes Zelle® great for urgent payments without waiting like you would for normal bank transfers.

How much you can send with Zelle® depends on your bank. Usually, you might be limited to about $500-$3,500 per day and $15,000-$20,000 per month. Some banks start with lower limits for new accounts and increase them over time.

Using Zelle® depends on how comfortable you are with your bank's app – you typically use it inside your banking app. There's no separate social feed like Venmo; it works more like a regular bank transfer. For many people (especially those who prefer traditional banking), this simplicity is appealing.

Zelle® uses bank-level security. However, fraud protection can be a problem – banks consider Zelle® payments like cash, so if you send money to a scammer, banks often won't help you get it back since you approved the payment. Zelle® is meant for sending money to people you know and trust.

Zelle® doesn't connect to online stores or other services. It focuses only on person-to-person transfers through banks.

Good Things About Zelle®:

  • Completely free (no fees to send or receive)
  • Nearly instant direct bank transfers
  • No need to cash out a separate balance
  • Available through many major banks (over 2,200 banks)
  • Feels secure since it works with your existing bank

Not-So-Good Things About Zelle®:

  • No credit card option or wallet feature
  • Limited features (no social feed, emojis, or built-in split functions)
  • Sending limits vary by bank and can be relatively low
  • Almost no purchase protection – risky to use with people you don't know

PayPal

PayPal is one of the oldest digital payment platforms, widely known for online shopping. For sending money to friends and family, PayPal offers a "Friends and Family" option similar to other money-sending apps.

You can connect PayPal to bank accounts, debit cards, or credit cards. Sending personal payments from a bank account or PayPal balance is free. Using a credit or debit card costs 2.9% + 30¢. Receiving personal transfers is free. PayPal also offers instant transfers to a bank or debit card for a 1.75% fee (minimum 25¢, maximum $25), while standard bank transfers (1-3 days) are free.

PayPal-to-PayPal payments happen instantly within their network. The person receiving the money can then use those funds via PayPal or transfer them to their bank. For splitting expenses or paying friends, PayPal works well but requires the extra step of cashing out compared to direct bank transfers like Zelle®.

PayPal's transfer limits for personal use are high. A verified account can send up to $60,000 in a single transaction (though limits may apply in some cases), which is more than enough for typical personal needs.

PayPal has a more traditional interface compared to Venmo or Cash App, showing its business-focused origins. The app offers many features including banking tools and cryptocurrency trading, which some users find complicated. PayPal has improved by adding features like bill-splitting, though this isn't as easy to find as in Venmo.

PayPal is well-established with strong security features, encryption, and fraud monitoring. Users can enable two-factor authentication for added protection. A key advantage for individuals is PayPal's buyer protection for "Goods & Services" transactions (though personal "Friends & Family" payments have no protection, similar to other money-sending apps).

PayPal works with millions of online stores. Users can shop online, donate to causes, or pay bills with their PayPal balance or connected accounts. PayPal also offers a Cashback Mastercard debit card for spending from the PayPal balance.

Good Things About PayPal:

  • Highly trusted platform that's been around for a long time
  • No fees for bank/balance personal payments
  • Very high sending limits
  • Optional purchase protection for goods/services transactions
  • Widely accepted beyond just person-to-person (works with many online stores)

Not-So-Good Things About PayPal:

  • Fees for credit card payments (2.9% + 30¢)
  • App isn't as simple as newer competitors
  • No support for people under 18
  • Personal transactions have no protection unless marked as purchases (which costs fees)

Cash App

Cash App has become popular for its simplicity and straightforward design – typically just a number pad to enter an amount and send/request money.

Cash App lets you keep a balance or connect bank accounts and cards. Sending money from a bank account or debit card is free, while using a credit card costs a 3% fee. Receiving money is also free. Transferring your balance to a bank gives you two options: Standard (free, 1-3 days) or Instant (0.5% to 1.75% fee, minimum 25¢).

Cash App to Cash App payments happen right away. The Cash Card (Visa debit card) lets you spend your balance immediately without waiting for bank transfers, and it works at stores, online, and ATMs (with a $2.50 fee for ATMs outside their network).

By default, Cash App caps unverified accounts at $1,000 total in any 30‑day period (about $250 a week). After you complete ID‑verification, most users can send up to about $10,000 in a rolling 7‑day window (and $20,000 over 30 days), while receiving limits are effectively removed—still lower than Venmo’s or PayPal’s top ceilings but plenty for day‑to‑day use. 

Cash App's design is simple and straightforward – even people who aren't tech-savvy find it easy to use. It doesn't have Venmo's social feed, which some people prefer for privacy reasons. Each user has a unique "$Cashtag" username, making it simple to request or send money.

A special feature of Cash App is that it offers Bitcoin and stock investing within the app. Users can buy Bitcoin or trade stocks with small amounts of money, adding value beyond just transfers. This combination of financial services makes it appealing to users looking for an all-in-one financial app.

Cash App uses encryption, PIN/fingerprint locks, and two-factor authentication. Like other money-sending apps, if you send money to the wrong person, you have limited options – payments are instant and typically can't be canceled once sent. Cash App does not offer protection on personal transfers.

Good Things About Cash App:

  • Very simple and quick to use
  • Free to send/receive with bank or debit
  • Instant transfers and free debit card for immediate access to funds
  • Extra features (Bitcoin, stock investing) included
  • Clean, private design without social features

Not-So-Good Things About Cash App:

  • 3% fee on credit card payments
  • Up to 1.75% fee for instant bank deposits
  • Lower sending limits compared to Venmo/PayPal
  • No protection for disputes
  • Sometimes targeted by scammers

Choosing Between Venmo, Zelle®, PayPal and Cash App: Real-Life Scenarios

  • Splitting a $180 dinner among five friends
  • Paying your half of shared utilities to a roommate
  • Buying a concert ticket from a friend of a friend
  • Reimbursing Mom for last‑minute travel booking

We evaluated each platform on out‑of‑pocket cost, UX friction, privacy controls, transfer speed and recourse if something goes wrong.

Compare Transfer Fees: Venmo, Zelle®, PayPal and Cash App Side by Side

Action Venmo Zelle® PayPal Cash App
Send $200 from checking $0 fee; recipient balance instant; bank cash‑out 1 day (free) or 1 min (1.75%) $0 fee; hits recipient's checking in minutes $0 fee (Friends & Family); recipient PayPal balance instant; bank cash‑out 1‑3 d (free) $0 fee; recipient balance instant; bank cash‑out 1‑3 d (free)
Send $200 via credit card $6 fee (3%) N/A (cards unsupported) $6.10 (2.9% + $0.30) $6 (3%)
Instantly withdraw $2,000 $35 (capped at $25) $0 (already in bank) $35 (capped at $25) $20–$35 (0.5–1.75%)

 

Limits

  • Venmo – $299.99 weekly send until identity verified; then ~$60 k per week across all payments.
  • Cash App – $250/week unverified, $20,000 per 30 days after ID‑verification.
  • PayPal – up to $60 k single txn for verified U.S. consumer.
  • Zelle® – bank‑controlled; typical retail limit $3,500/day & $20 k/mo.

Payment App Limits & Transfer Speeds: Venmo vs Zelle® vs PayPal vs Cash App

Feature Venmo Zelle® PayPal Cash App
Max Personal Send Limit Verified: $6,999.99/week (P2P); $60k/week overall Varies by Bank (e.g., $500-$2500+/day) Verified: Up to $60,000/transaction Verified: $7,500/week
P2P Transfer Speed (User-to-User) Instant (to Venmo Balance) Minutes (Direct to Bank) Instant (to PayPal Balance) Instant (to Cash App Balance)
Standard Cash-Out Speed (to Bank) 1-3 Business Days N/A 1-3+ Business Days 1-3 Business Days
Standard Cash-Out Fee Free N/A Free Free
Instant Cash-Out Speed Minutes N/A Minutes Minutes
Instant Cash-Out Fee 1.75% (Min $0.25, Max $25) N/A 1.75% (Min $0.25, Max $25) 0.5% - 1.75% (Min $0.25)

 

Which Payment App Has the Best Features? Venmo vs Zelle® vs PayPal vs Cash App

Feature Venmo Zelle® PayPal Cash App
Public / friends timeline Yes (default public; can set to private) No No No
Split button Yes – auto compute shares No Moderate – "Split a bill" flow Manual (request multiple)
Contact discovery Phone, email, QR Phone, email (via bank) Phone, email $Cashtag, phone, QR
Dark‑mode & accessibility Full Bank app‑dependent Full Full

 

Privacy‑sensitive users often prefer Cash App or PayPal because no transaction feed is exposed by default; Venmo users can mitigate by toggling “Private” globally.

Payment App Fraud Protection Guide: How Venmo, Zelle®, PayPal & Cash App Handle Problems

Problem Venmo Zelle® PayPal Cash App
Send to wrong person Ask them to send back; Venmo can try to help Money is gone unless they refund Same as Venmo Same as Venmo
Pay a scam seller Little help unless you used a business profile Little help Buyer Protection if you marked it "Goods & Services" Little help
Account hacked Covered; app has PIN & 2-step sign-in Covered by bank rules Covered Covered